Do you think Sonia Sotomayor will change the direction of the Supreme Court?
Live Poll
Do you think Sonia Sotomayor will change the direction of the Supreme Court?
Do you think Sonia Sotomayor will change the direction of the Supreme Court?
VoteTotal Votes: 1270
She'll be able to easier screw over White Males.
If you really believe that Tommy$, then you deserve to get screwed over.
I don't even know what her being "able to easier screw over White Males" means. This will provide her a platform to more easily punish white guys for being white? What kind of cyclical racist logic is that?
What a carefully worded set of biased ballot questions. She is either mainstream or independent? What a crock, she is a Democrat tool and will do as she is told by her puppet masters. We already know that she supports La Raza, a racist organization, has passed racially biased judgements and tried to hide her rulings in order to get appointed.
An Obama tool for an Obamanation, an all assault against whitey is imminent.
hey, don't bother supporting that with any actual evidence.
let's see-Evidence #1-the Hate in her face when answering the questions about comments and decisions she made public?
Esp the Racial Comments she made IN PUBLIC? Is THAT evidence enough for you, or when she shoves your rights down the TOILET, maybe THAT will be good enough?
Some of us see the writing on the wall and go OH, Shxx, it's Obama's Hitman come to take and ban and Tax and change the Country for the Police state we Know he Wants.
Then again, like a certain David Compton, you can bury your head in the sand and pretend Dems "know what's best for everyone" (ROTFLMAO)
You base your delusion of the rights of Americans being flushed down the toilet and a your conspiracy theory that Pres. Obama wants to turn America into a police state on what you perceive to be a hateful expression on someone's face? You'll disregard Judge Sotomayor's entire judicial history based on one comment that has been stretched thinner than paper into a "scathingly racist" remark? That is just silly. Maybe you should challenge your sources of information once in a while.
Isn't it unfortunate that we have come so far in this country toward getting rid of racial prejudices by electing a black president and now a Supreme Court justice who is hispanic, yet we still have to read such racist remarks as have been espoused in some of these postings.
Those posting comments that Sotomayer is racist should read what they themselves have posted! If you are basing your conclusions on the Ricci case, the appeals court followed the existing precedent of the Supreme Court when they made their decision. They could not create precedent! When the case came before the Supreme Court, the SC changed the precedent. This was their ability to re-interpret law or their understanding of the law as it is written in the Constitution or amendments.
However, if you base your conclusion on the much heard "wise latina" statement, perhap you should read the statement in the context in which it was given. When taken out of context, the comment does, indeed, sound racist. Read in context, however, the phrase is not racist. The worst that Judge Sotomayer could be accused of is a bad choice of words! Had the judge used the word "woman" instead of latina, would you then have attacked her because she was a woman?
Thirdly, if you think the judge will change the court alignment, don't be too sure. She was first appointed to the bench by George H. W. Bush, a republican! She was appointed to the appeals court by Bill Clinton, a democrat! If anything, the judge is a centerist, neither republican or democrat, and her rulings have shown that. How does this make her a left-wing nut case?
The right just needs to make sure they hold the other side of the isle to the same demands they made. Basically telling the right to "confirm or else" is a sad day. I know she wont change direction of the present court but to have her confirmed is a real shame. I'm sure she is a great lady but not a great jurist. Those or two totally separate things. There will be another change coming soon I'm sure and Obama will leave his misguided legacy for all Americans to pay for.
What a sad, pathetic excuse for an American you are, Leon.
Leon is an example of the poor state of American education. We have too many idiots
who can't string intelligent sentences together and contradict themselves 2 or 3 times in
their ranting.
Has anyone noticed that if you disagree with President Obama, you are called narrow-minded - sad - pathetic - etc. ? And I thought we still had free speech . . .
Leon spoke how he felt and that's part of what America is all about - being able to say how you feel and hopefully not be attacked for it.
I believe that Sotomayer is a grave mistake and am concerned about 'emotional decisions' instead of judging the best she can by the law. It's not because she's a woman, it's because she already made it clear that she has more wisdom because she's a female Latina. If a "white" person made that statement, it'd be all she wrote because that 'white' person would be branded a bigot. She says that and she's not a bigot? Hmmmmm, I smell double standard here . . .
Leon, What legacy did Bush leave??? We will be suffering for years to come, but hell, we can blame that on Obama . Sotomayer will be a good chief justice and treat everyone with equal respect under the law. We need that, this country does not need to favor any race, what's good for one is good for all. This habit of saying white men this and white men is ,in poor taste. We all make up America, and should be respected as such. I don't care about anyone's color, religion, status, or life style. I treat you right, I expect you to treat me the same; the problem comes when fools think because they are a different color they are superior, NOT SO;, we are all equal, being smarter, having wealthy, being beautiful or handsome, does not keep one from dying. So by the grace of God we are all Equal, otherwise, the exceptional ones would live "Forever". When that happens we will all know, we are no longer "Equal." Don't worry it will never happen!!!!!
Has anyone noticed that if you disagree with President Obama, you are called narrow-minded - sad - pathetic - etc. ? And I thought we still had free speech . . .
Free speech extends both ways. You can say whatever you want about the President, but you have to accept his supporters saying what they want about you. Deal with it.
She says that and she's not a bigot?
Does one statement a racist make? Do you have any other evidence besides this overblown comment that Sotomayor has admitted was a poor attempt at word play? (Before you bring up the firefighter case, I'll remind you that one of the plaintiffs in that case was Hispanic and that 4 out of 5 current Supreme Court judges agreed with her)
Doesn't matter how many times a racist says how they feel-some are good at hiding it, and only slip "Once". Nice thing is, sometimes it only takes "Once". UNfortunately, Several slips aren't good enough to dislodge a "Favorite" until they have enough time to do severe Damage to the country as a Whole.
Funny how the last part of her "wise Latina" comment gets ignored. She said it with a qualification, relating her wisdom to her experiences; she compared her wisdom to that of an inexperienced white male. And this is radical? Right. Whenever white males don't have the world handed to them, there must be something wrong with the system, not them.
What a sad, pathetic excuse for an American you are, Leon.
...
Leon is an example of the poor state of American education. We have too many idiots
who can't string intelligent sentences together and contradict themselves 2 or 3 times in
their ranting.
Ed-743399, Allen A., you're each suspended for a day for violating #1 of the Code of Honor.
Also, there's no guarantee anyone on Newsvine's an American, though many users are.
The ideological balance of the US Supreme Court, if Sotomayor behaves as expected in a liberal manner, will not change. Souter was a liberal Justice as well.
Very Mainstream person. Just cuz she's Hispanic isn't cause for alarm. Those that fear her are either extremist or scared of their own shaddow.
It's not a case of being uncomfortable or alarmed BECAUSE she's Hispanic. It's just soooo obvious that Obama nominated HER mainly BECAUSE she's Hispanic and he's ALREADY campaigning for the Hispanic vote. Only time will tell how she adjudicates. Just don't think that ever entered Obama's mind...just get a HISPANIC and a WOMAN on the bench to endear himself to both of those groups of voters. I think, and hope that both women and Hispanics can and will make their OWN decisions and not feel beholden to such an obvious seduction.
Bush put Clarence Thomas on the bench, was he trying to endear himself to blacks???? Bad,Bad choice if he was, and I sure didn't feel obligated to vote for him or John McCain. People make up their own minds, and most of us think. I'm educated , I read and I research then I decide. It would help this country if you Obama haters tried thinking outside the "BOX" but you'd have to have "A BRAIN" to do that.
and what of the Hispanics that think she is a bad choice, are they extreme and paranoid, or do they lack the rich cultural experience to make a wise decision?
I fear for This Wonderful Country Of Mine. God Bless America and God Help Us All. Note what I say. Our Constitution Is In Danger from these radical Liberals. Wake Up Americans and vote them out of office.
The Ole Sarge.. Korean & Vietnam DAV.
We Live in The best Country In The World and you all are letting it slip through your fingers.
Our Constitution was in deep trouble before Sotomayor and Obama came along. Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Rove, and Reagan all trashed it. It IS the best country in the world, and now we can rescue it from the corporate fascists and the neoconservatives.
You think Reagan, Bush, Cheney, and Rumsfeld have trashed our constitution so the Democrates can rescue it from the corporate fascists and the neoconservatives. Then what the H*** do you call government motors, the proposed health care reform? They are taking away private industry and trying to take away our right to health care with our doctors (not the ones the government will tell us we can see). We are becoming the old Russia.
Thank you Master Sargent Trovini for your service to our country.
Think for yourself Frosty Express . . . don't listen to the talking heads on the right . . . btw why was it alright for bush to give the banks billions with no strings attached ? ? ?
Yes, we will see this nation change. The New World Order is nearly on stage and will triumph on the field....for a time. Many states are being urged to convene a ConCon and revise The Constitution. Our media has sucessfully divided Americans against one another without them suspecting the ruse.
Well, I hold onto my principles and tolerate everything thrown at me, but my eyes and ears are open nonetheless. The best of life and luck to you and all out there.
M/Sgt Joesph Trovini USAF Retired, Our country is doing alright and it still belongs to All of us. I serviced in the Air Force too, Korean Conflict and Vietnam, as did my husband and his two brothers. I might, add we are all retired Air Force and proud of it; In the words of John F. Kennedy," ask not what your country can do for you, but rather, what you can do for your country" I believe in that. This country has taken a severe beating for eight long years and at the rate we are going it will be many more before it ends. History teaches us that a Nation divided against it's self can not stand, and with all this pulling, bickering, back biting and crazyness of parties and people, we are very near the end. My only wish is that God would send another "ARK", damn I need one.
Mary, i served as well, and learned to spell properly long before that-if you need an ark to save you from Obama, welcome to it-but dont downplay the Damage this "New Order" is creating for itself, and Definitely Remember-THIS is the FIRST President in the History of the USA to APOLOGISE to TERRORISTS-and George W Bush was the one who WENT AFTER THE TERRORISTS-bad info or NOT, he DID something instead of Promises with No Resolution like Clinton et al. As far as the "Bad Info" goes-i have to tell you all-There Were some things there, and Why it wasn't Publicized We'll never know, But i SAW with my Own Eyes parts for Nukes, Parts for Chemical Weapons and some serious business Saddam was up to was Hidden, so play the clinton game all you want, but Be Aware there's stuff that Never was told to us-Find out Why, rather than blame President Bush for all the Bad stuff. Think before parroting the "Party Line".
Our way of life is in for a significant change for the worst. Our country as we know it will never be the same when it come to our legal system. Those that think this is a great day will never understand that the supreme court is suppose to check the constitution and compare it to the brief brought before them. Not what they feel is right or what other people want it to be. Pray for rescue of our country from the extreme left.
I could not have said it better myself. I ‘m glad someone on here actually understands what is happening. Most of these posters are extremely naïve and that scares me most of all! And I don't appreciate how leading the poll above is! None of the three responses clearly express what I feel: that she is a very sad excuse for a juror who will (probably) make rulings based on personal feelings and not on what is fair and a good interpretation of the constitution. (Or at least that is what she seems like based on her political history. Hopefully she will be better than that, but since she was nominated by Obama I'm not betting on it.) I'll be praying that she is better than she seems based on her past decisions!
You need a reality check Frosty Express . . . the country is center left . . . of course if your as far right as the 'drugster' everything else looks extreme left . . . every justice on the court bring their personal feelings to work everyday, and have said as much . . .
You had better pray for yourselves and forgiveness, putting anyone down because they don't measure up to the Republicans "way of life". I'm not sure what that is except 24/7 saying no to everything (as a group) might i say, and damming any idea that is brought up by anyone that isn't a Republican. It's really strange that you call our President , racist when your party is the one that is spreading the hate, name calling, lies and promoting unrest at every level. "God Bless our President" and our country. All we have to do is get out of the mess that eight years of your beloved right got us into......
Thats what got us in this mess, dems voted for a president that didnt measure up, NO EXPERIANCE, None < Hows that community organizer working out for YOU?
And the extreme right, too, Frosty Express. Our current way of life favours EXTREMES and subtly supports it.
I do hope Judge Sotomayor will be a great success. She has a brilliant mind and cares deeply about the world we live in. I love her!
Didnt you say the same thing When Obama won? Democrat ignorance at its finest, (Hows the change working out for Now!!!!!!!!!)
"Democratic ignorance at its finest." No! Every question, every issue has two sides. Each and every issue needs to be examined without this hysterical partisianship, which often all too often is so evident.
A vote has been taken and now, for better or for worse, the well worn vow we take at the marriage alter, we have Sonya Sotomayor as Supreme Court Justice.
Your tool is the ballot box. Cast your vote, always.
Sure, give her a fair chance! Just leave the 2nd Amendment alone and allow me to protect myself and other citizens from harm.
This is another sad sad day for America. She brings with her an agenda and racism
Linda, we already have a lots of racism , let's hope she bring an agenda that the other judicist will allow her to use, remember she's only one person and there are 11 others. The Supreme Court sat back and allowed prayer to be taken out of school and defaced our money by removing in "God We Trust", that too was a Sad,Sad day for America. I didn't vote for it , did you???
Here we go ; more affirmative action (discrimination against white males) abortion (kill more innocent unborn) on demond, weak national defense and erosion of our freedoms, and increased freedoms for our enemies.
Shame on you Congress. I guess President Bush's hispanic nomination wasn't liberal enough for the left wing loonies that dominate the democratic party.
And for those "republicats" who voted for her; we will remember you when you come up for re-election.
Can you give me the name of a white male judge more qualified than her? You're not being discriminated against when 98% of the court has been white.
In fact, can you give me any evidence at all that Sotomayor's rulings give any precedence to the things you say?
I am sorry to tell; but it is the truth. All those regreting Judge Sotomayor's confirmation are guilty of what you accuse her of; racism. Why didn't you Republicans objected when Judges Thomas and Alito were nominated and confirmed. Simply because you have grown accustomed to african/americans who believe they are white (and think as such) and to assian/americans who do not represent a threat in terms of numbers. Hispanics are now the largest minority in the USA and you fear our growing influence in the country's issues. At least nine Republican senators were smart enough to realize the truth. Do not fear persons either of hispanic birthplace or of hispanic heritage. Although it may be hard for some of you to understand, we will only make this Nation greater.
Number 1 - I do not fear Hispanics. I fear any person who thinks they are better than anyone else in any ethnic group i.e. Sotomayer thinks she's better than white people because she's a female Latina. yeah . . . that's open-minded and engenders trust.
Number 2 - If we only count the legal Hispanics and do not include the illegal immigrants, are you still the largest minority?
Number 3 - I don't believe that any one group will necessarily make our nation greater. I believe our nation will become greater when we cast aside what makes us different and join together as one unified country: there are no African Americans, Hispanic Americans, Asian Americans - we are just Americans - period ! ALL nationalities help make this nation greater when they give their best to this country.
Geezzzz!!!! to quote and old friend "Bob Dole doesn't need this crap". We really don't need a racist as a Supreme Court Justice. Also we need someone that will interpret the laws, not make them. Maybe being out in the bright light will cause her to do the right thing when the time comes.
I am very proud that we have all come so far as Americans. From what I read about her, she is very intelligent and strong. She has good morals, strong history and she is not afraid to speak her mind. However, some people would like to put a negative spin on anything instead of understanding what someone is saying. I think she would make an excellent SC judge. I did not vote for Obama but I wish I had. Unlike, Bush he is not on vacation every few seconds and seems to be focused on many different issues at hand. Bush threw so much money out that is still not accounted for with no written plans for it. Thats not thinking about the working class... the middle class. Obama wants to focus on our health care as well as our economy and all our other problems. I don't vote for parties, I vote for change. I feel confident in his choice of Sotomayor, especially after all I read about her. I feel she will bring forth change and in a positive way.
Ed your are so fast to to judge others, im thinking your just another right winger thats like the hand out taken from others,So i heard yours and read mine( Love Freedom of speech) no free heath care , no special programs , no acorn, replace the congress and the senate with republicans and take back starting with impeachment proceedings for wreckless spending of taxPAYER dollars< and also combat illegals aliens and return them home. and people who dont pay taxes should not be allowed to vote , No Money ,no say That way the dem s wont have any votes<
she never would have made it had she not said what she did biased is the way to be with all politicians
Congratulations to Judge Sotomayor. I believe Ms. Sotomayor is a very main stream person and will help bring civility and stability to the Supreme Court bench. I believe much of the contentiosness of the recent debate has to do with my perceived reality that much of conservative America is not yet ready to receive a person of her ethnicity and gender to fill this important post.
I am a white caucasian male, 71 years of age. I am now seeing the third generation of Americans come to maturity since the Supreme Court descision Brown vs. the Board of Education and the subsequent integration of all public schools. The relaxation of racial tension has been a long, slow and continuing process. This watershed moment has drawn many other movements into a continuing eddy of social change. Ms. Sotomayor has been very much a part and product of these moments. Her ascendency to the Supreme Court is symbolic of the success of these movements.
I don't know about S.C or her but Obama just got himself elected for another term. Now the Hispanic voters will vote for him for the same reason the African Americans did. Just plain blind hero worship.Hero worshippers do not have the intellectual capacity to think and rationalize. America ,be ready for another ten years of hell. May be more for the supreme court. Those people don't have term limit.
Why only 10 years?
Watch and see if Obama doesn't want to find a way to weasel around the 22nd Amendment. then we'll be stuck with this guy forever since Democrats can pass on their elected offices to their wives and children (check out Chicago, Cook county and Illinois if you haven't heard about that one).
One of the things that make our country America what she is the strength and stability of our institutions, among them our three part heads of goverment, the legislative, the court and the executive. There are set procedures for making changes. So what's this 10 year business and getting around the 22nd amendment? These kinds of statements come out of nowhere and only add static noise to serious discussions about serious matters
I don't know about S.C or her but Obama just got himself elected for another term. Now the Hispanic voters will vote for him for the same reason the African Americans did. Just plain blind hero worship.Hero worshippers do not have the intellectual capacity to think and rationalize. America ,be ready for another ten years of hell. May be more for the supreme court. Those people don't have term limit.
Jockonox
I am a USA citizen, although not born in continental USA soil. If I had, I would have written the precise, correct and beautiful things you said.
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. You're in XHTML Mode. If you prefer, you can use Easy Mode instead. (XHTML tags allowed - a,b,blockquote,br,code,dd,dl,dt,del,em,h2,h3,h4,i,ins,li,ol,p,pre,q,strong,ul) |
Very Mainstream. Those who see her as out there are extermists.